Monday, August 31, 2026

Bridge Blog 1205: Slip-up

 

Want further proof that technology renders us helpless at simple tasks that used to be performed without a hitch by hand? Look no further than the annual Unit 116 picnic and game on Saturday, Aug. 29.

No hitches in the picnic part of the day. The food – roast chicken, potatoes, salads and the fabulous sweet corn picked that very morning from the fields at Paul Zittel's farm – was very much up to the standards set in previous years.

No, the breakdown didn't come until the game started, after some initial confusion about who was sitting where in a setup that spread 18 tables through all four playrooms at the Buffalo Bridge Center. The confusion over table assignments soon turned into confusion on the BridgeMates, the electronic scoring devices. After director Art Morth wasn't able to set them straight, he gave each table pick-up slips, little scoring cards for each round.

I hadn't seen a pick-up slip since before the pandemic, when director Bill Finkelstein favored them at the Airport Bridge Club. Since I was sitting East, I didn't have to deal with them. That challenge fell upon the players sitting North, since they’re in charge of scorekeeping, and many of them had forgotten how to fill the damn things out.

At one table, I coached North from start to finish on which figures went where. Several others also weren't sure what information went on which line. And forget about finding out how well or how badly you did when the game was over. There were no results right away.

There wasn't the usual email from the ACBL with results on Saturday night, either. There still wasn't one Sunday afternoon. It took until 9:52 p.m. Sunday for that familiar Live for Clubs message to show up. That was followed 15 minutes later by another email, this one from help@thecommongame.com. It read:

Dear Dale & Judy (sic),

Your reported score below looks highly unusual. Please do NOT reply to this email. IF this was scored on the wrong side or in error, please report this to your club director ASAP. ... While this might not impact your standing or masterpoint awards, it could affect someone else's.

 

Board #13

Score -600

Opponent #18

Your direction EW

 

The information for the Contract was blank, but the score suggests either a successful North-South bid of 3 No Trump vulnerable or us going down six vulnerable. According to the hand record that accompanied the email message, neither of those things was likely to happen. I dug out my personal tally of the hands and, sure enough, we didn't get minus 600 on Board 13. We got minus 200. How come?

I had snatched the bid from North-South, Pat Haynes and Agi Maisel, keeping them from playing it at 2 Spades. I went to 3 Diamonds – my opening bid was a Diamond, since I had four of them and no five-card major – and felt confident because my partner Judie Bailey had raised Diamonds. This was going to be a sacrifice. I fully expected to fall one trick short for a score of minus 100. On the other hand, if Pat and Agi made 2 Spades, and I reckoned they would, our score would be minus 110. This is why they say down one is good bridge.

When the dummy appeared, though, my heart sank. I saw only three Diamonds in Judie's hand. Didn't her bid promise four of them? Shouldn't she have mentioned her five-card Heart suit? In Hearts, according to the hand record, we win eight tricks. As the Diamonds stand, we're good for only seven. Draw all the Diamonds and play it like it's No Trump? Still good for only seven.

East (me)

Spades: J-10-5; Hearts: A-J-6; Diamonds: Q-6-5-2; Clubs: K-5-4.

South (Agi)

Spades: A-9-4; Hearts: Q-10-9-3; Diamonds: 8-7; Clubs: 9-8-7-3.

West (Judie)

Spades: 8-6; Hearts: K-8-7-5-2; Diamonds: K-J-10; Clubs: A-J-6.

North (Pat)

Spades: K-Q-7-3-2; Hearts: 4; Diamonds: A-9-4-3; Clubs: Q-10-2.

Minus 600 was an absolute bottom board. Minus 200 tied us for bottom with two other East-Wests and gave us about 1.25 more match points. Our final score went up from 44-something percent to 45.44%. I hoped it would at least take us from 14th place to 13th among the East-Wests, but no-o-o-o. Marilyn Wortzman and Jim Easton still were in front of us. By 0.06%.

No comments:

Post a Comment