The main thing was we had a good time, partner Florence Boyd declares at the end of Saturday's special game and annual meeting at the Buffalo Bridge Center. No doubt about it, fun was had. For one thing, Florence said, this is the first time she bid a slam and made it.
Nevertheless, we're next-to-last North-South in a 10-table event and we couldn't even muster 40%. We're 39.37% and, as denizens of the A strat, we need at least 56%, or 28 more match points, to beat Martha Welte and Howard Foster (55.83%) to go home with master points.
How many hands would it take to turn around to close that massive gap? We can't do it, not without some gifts from our opponents. And how did the first-place North-South pair, Jay Levy and Kamil Bishara (66.29%), fare on those same boards?
Board 10. First cards of the day. Davis Heussler and David Colligan, the eventual East-West champs, wind up at 2 No Trump, making three. No overtrick at the other table where NT was bid. Possible gain: 0.5 match point. Jay and Kamil bid 2 Spades, despite having just 20 high card points between them, and make 2 overtricks. Possible match point gain if we do that: 5.
Board 11. David plays it at 1 NT and goes down two. Jay and Kamil, along with two other North-Souths, take this bid at 2 Hearts with just 16 high card points between them, and make 2 overtricks, (North has a six-card suit.) Possible match point gain if Florence bid it: 2.5.
Board 12. Davis and David, with 10 Hearts between them, go all the way up to 5 Hearts. I have a 7-card Spade suit, King-Queen-Jack, etc., and I climb the ladder with them to 5 Spades. Florence shows her hand and, if a Diamond finesse works (Florence has Q-J-10, I have three to the Ace), we have just two losers -- Ace of Spades and Ace of Clubs. But no, West (David) has the King. Should we let them play it at 5 Hearts? That's down three. Double them and possible point gain is 3.5. Jay and Bishara get to play it at 4 Spades.
Board 13. Florence plays it at 3 NT, makes two overtricks. So do Jay and Kamil. Can't do better than that.
Board 14. Not vulnerable, with J-10-7-4-2 in Spades, I open a Spade, even though my hand falls one point short of the Rule of 15 and the Rule of 20. Florence, with three Spades and 16 high card points, bids 2 Spades. We take three overtricks. If North bids a five-card Heart suit instead of giving me a simple raise, we wind up in game and take 10 tricks. Possible match point gain: 2.5 in No Trump, 3.5 if it's Spades. Jay and Kamil also make three overtricks at 2 Spades.
Board 15. Florence's 6 NT slam with an overtrick. Five other pairs, including Jay and Kamil, do the same thing.
Board 16. Larry Abate and Jim Lanzo bid 3 NT, make one more overtrick than the one other 3 NT bidder. Every other East-West, including the pair at Jay and Kamil's table, bids 4 Hearts and makes it with no overtricks. Possible match point gain if I get my Queen of Hearts trick: 0.5.
Board 17. We pass it out. Third best score out of eight. North has an opening 1 Diamond bid, though, and we can take 10 or 11 tricks in Hearts. Possible match point gain: 1.
Board 18 1 NT by South. In all, five North-Souths, including Jay and Kamil, bid that and make it.
Board 19. I blow a 4 Spade contract against Julie Mitchell and Brian Fleming. Everybody else makes it, some with overtricks. Bottom board. Minimum match point gain: 3. Jay and Kamil don't play Boards 19, 20 and 21.
Board 20. We stop at 3 Spades despite having 27 high card points between us, make an overtrick. Another bottom board. Most other North-Souths play it at 3 NT with overtricks. Minimum match point gain: 4.5.
Board 21. In a display of great defensive bidding, Julie and Brian take the bid at 4 Spades and go down one. Had they left us at 4 Hearts, we make it. Possible match point gain: 1.5.
Board 22. We both have opening hands. I push Florence to 3 NT, but we don't have a stopper in Hearts. At a couple tables, East-Wests don't discover that and North-South run off five Club tricks and four Diamonds. Our opponents, Linda Marsh and Art Ziller, find it, take five Hearts and the A-K of Spades. No Jay and Kamil for Boards 22, 23 and 24 either.
Board 25. Opponents Walt Olszewski and Sushil Amlani shouldn't make an overtrick at 4 Hearts, but they do. We get the Ace of Diamonds, Queen of Hearts and ought to get a trick with Florence's Jack of Spades or Queen of Clubs. Possible match point gain: 1. Jay and Kamil do better, thanks to their opponents, who play 3 NT, no overtricks.
Board 26. I play it at 2 Hearts, so does Kamil. I make one overtrick, he makes three. Possible match point gain: 2.5.
Board 27. Walt and Sushil bid and make 5 Diamonds. Jay and Kamil get a gift from their opponents. Their East-Wests take 12 tricks, but only bid 3 Spades.
Board 28. I take 11 tricks in a 3 Diamond contract. So do Jay and Kamil, who bid 4 Diamonds.
Board 29. Pretty much all of the East-Wests bid 4 Spades and make 4 Spades. Same with us and Jay-Bishara.
Board 30. This time I'm at 5 Diamonds, opening 3 Diamonds with seven of them headed A-K-Q. Tova and Andrei Reinhorn go to 4 Spades vulnerable, which they can make. Down 2. Bottom board avoided. Jay and Bishara are down 1 at 4 Diamonds.
Board 1. Jay and Bishara are at 4 Hearts, down one. So are we, except Bill and Nathan Kross double us. Possible match point gain if they don't: 1.5.
Board 2. We set Bill and Nathan by one trick at 4 Hearts. Same with Jay and Kamil against a 3 NT contract.
Board 3. I bid 3 NT, make 3 overtricks. So do Jay and Kamil.